By Tony Kawaguchi, REALTOR, The Kawaguchi Group, eXp Realty. Updated November 2026.
![]()
Quick answer: A VA compromise sale is VA's older name for a VA short sale: you sell the home for less than you owe, and the servicer accepts the sale proceeds and releases the lien, with VA paying a claim under its guaranty. VA's rule (38 CFR 36.4322(e)) requires that the servicer find the loan insoluble, that the sale net at least VA's net value for the property, and that you receive no proceeds. Borrowers who live in the home can get $1,500 in VA relocation assistance at closing. If your loan closed on or after January 1, 1990, you generally won't owe VA the loss unless there was fraud, misrepresentation, or bad faith, but you must repay that loss to restore the entitlement used on the loan.
Sources: 38 CFR 36.4319 and 36.4322; VA Servicer Handbook M26-4, Chapter 5 (effective June 1, 2026); VA.gov "VA help to avoid foreclosure"; 38 U.S.C. §§ 3702 and 3703(e). Checked November 20, 2026.
Here's a situation we see on Oahu: a service member bought a condo or townhome with zero down, values went flat, and now PCS orders have arrived and the sale price, after costs, won't cover the loan. The Oahu condo median has sat near $510,000 since 2022 and slipped to $499,000 in October 2026 (Honolulu Board of REALTORS). With little or no money down, and selling costs on top, a flat market can leave an owner underwater.
For years, VA called this a compromise sale, and the claim VA paid afterward a compromise claim. In a May 9, 2024 VA bulletin announcing revisions to VA Servicer Handbook M26-4, Chapter 5, VA said it was changing the term "compromise sale" to "short sale" throughout the chapter. You'll still hear "compromise sale" from servicers, loan officers, and Veterans, and in older VA documents. It's the same transaction.
VA's definition, in M26-4 section 5.08, is a sale to a third party for less than the borrower's total eligible indebtedness on the loan. The servicer agrees to release the lien in exchange for the sale proceeds. VA says it should be considered "when a private sale is not feasible due to little or no equity."
Under 38 CFR 36.4322(e), a servicer can approve a short sale without asking VA first when all three of these are true:
| Condition | What it means for you |
|---|---|
| 1. The loan is insoluble | The servicer decides you can't realistically cure the loan. VA's manual says that if you're 60 or more days behind and ask for a short sale, the servicer doesn't have to review your income, expenses, and debts first. If you're current, expect a hardship review. |
| 2. The sale nets at least VA's net value | Net value is the fair market value from a VA liquidation appraisal, minus VA's estimated costs to acquire and resell the property (36.4322(c)). The proceeds plus anything the holder waives must meet or beat it. A liquidation appraisal is generally good for 180 days, and VA can shorten that to as few as 90 in a fast-moving market. |
| 3. You get no proceeds | You can't walk away with cash from the sale. The VA relocation payment below is the one exception VA builds in. |
If a sale doesn't meet all three, the servicer can ask VA for advance approval when it believes the short sale is in the best interest of the Veteran and the government (36.4322(e)(2)). Offers that come in under net value can sometimes still be approved this way.
As of June 1, 2026, M26-4 Chapter 5 requires servicers to work through VA's Loss Mitigation Waterfall. If you want to keep the home, the servicer reviews home-retention options in order. If you don't, it discusses "alternatives to foreclosure to include a private sale, short sale, and deed-in-lieu of foreclosure."
| If you want to keep the home | If you want or need to leave |
|---|---|
| Special forbearance; repayment plan; traditional VA modification; 30-year modification; VA Partial Claim (once you're at least 3 full months behind); 40-year modification | More time to arrange a private sale; short sale (compromise sale); deed in lieu of foreclosure |
The VA Partial Claim is new. VA pays your missed payments to bring the loan current, and you repay VA when you sell or pay off the loan. VA.gov says servicers have until November 28, 2026 to add it to their systems. If you want to keep the Hawaii home and rent it out, ask about it before you agree to a short sale.
VA's incentive works on two levels:
This is the part most people get wrong. Two separate questions apply:
1. Do you owe VA money? According to VA help to avoid foreclosure and 38 U.S.C. § 3703(e), if your loan closed on or after January 1, 1990, you generally don't have to repay what VA paid the servicer unless VA finds fraud, misrepresentation, or bad faith. For loans that closed before 1990, VA may seek repayment, and VA describes a waiver process. One exception: the post-1989 protection doesn't cover someone who assumed the loan and paid, or was exempt from, the assumption funding fee.
2. Can you use that entitlement again? VA.gov says that if your loan ends in a short sale, deed in lieu, or foreclosure, "you'll need to pay back the amount we lost on your loan to restore your future benefit." Until you do, the entitlement used on the Hawaii loan stays charged. You may still have remaining entitlement for another VA loan (see the VA.gov eligibility page), but in a high-cost area it may not cover a zero-down purchase.
For a PCSing owner, that's often the deciding factor. If you plan to buy with a VA loan at your next base, ask a VA loan technician or a VA lender to estimate your remaining entitlement before you choose a short sale over renting the home out, a loan modification, or an assumption.
![]()
VA doesn't publish a standard short sale timeline. In past Oahu short sales our team has handled, which weren't all VA loans, approvals have taken anywhere from under 90 days to about four and a half months. If you have a report date, start well before it.
| Option | When it fits | Entitlement effect |
|---|---|---|
| Rent it out | Rent plus BAH changes cover the payment, and you can manage from afar with an on-island agent. Hawaii law requires one if you live off-island. | Entitlement stays in use, but there's no VA loss. See renting out your Hawaii home when you PCS. |
| Sell by assumption | Your loan is current and your rate is low. A buyer may take over the loan at a price near the balance, so you don't need to bring cash or ask for a short sale. | Restored if a Veteran buyer substitutes entitlement. See VA assumable loans in Hawaii. |
| Loan modification or VA Partial Claim | You want to keep the home and can make payments going forward. | No claim, so no loss to repay. |
| Private sale, paying the difference | The shortfall is small and you can cover it in cash. | Restored when the loan is paid in full. |
| Deed in lieu | A short sale isn't practical. Title has to be clear of other liens, and you leave the home "broom clean." | Like a short sale. Any VA loss must be repaid to restore. |
| Foreclosure | The last resort. Hawaii allows judicial and nonjudicial foreclosure under HRS Chapter 667. | Any VA loss must be repaid to restore. This option also does the most damage to your credit. |
Being underwater with orders in hand is a timing problem as much as a money problem. Any of these three can start the servicer call with you.
Ryan spent 13 years in the Army and knows what a report date does to a sale timeline. He builds the net sheet that shows the servicer the real shortfall.
Jet, a Navy veteran, compares the short sale against renting and an at-balance assumption so you see what each does to your entitlement.
Lorraine, a Navy spouse, handles the listing and showings after you have flown out, so the sale keeps moving while you check in at the next base.
I'm Aloha Tony. I've sold Oahu homes since 2005, and I worked short sales in the years after 2008, when one servicer answer could take months. Step one costs nothing: a net sheet for your home next to your payoff, with renting, assuming, and short-selling priced side by side.
Call or text me at (808) 201-3577, email tony@alohatony.com, or send a message. Our Hawaii home selling guide and the Hawaii PCS guide cover the rest of a move off the island.
VA rewrote its loss mitigation chapter effective June 1, 2026, and may revise it again. Confirm your options with your servicer and a VA loan technician, and get tax advice on any forgiven debt. Not legal, tax, credit, or lending advice.
It's VA's older name for a VA short sale. You sell the home to a third party for less than you owe, and the servicer accepts the proceeds and releases the lien, with VA paying a claim under its guaranty. In 2024, VA changed the term in its Servicer Handbook M26-4 from compromise sale to short sale, but the transaction is the same.
VA's rule doesn't set a number of missed payments. It requires the servicer to find the loan insoluble. If you're 60 or more days past due and ask for a short sale, VA's manual says the servicer doesn't have to review your finances first. If you're current, expect a hardship review. Never miss payments on purpose.
VA lets servicers pay $1,500 in relocation assistance to borrower occupants who complete a short sale or deed in lieu, and VA reimburses the servicer. It's paid at closing under a written agreement. Separately, VA pays servicers $1,000, $800, or $600 per completed short sale, depending on their tier. That money goes to the servicer, not to you.
If your VA loan closed on or after January 1, 1990, VA says you generally won't have to repay what it paid the servicer unless it finds fraud, misrepresentation, or bad faith. Loans closed before 1990 can be different. Either way, you must repay VA's loss to restore the entitlement used on that loan.
Possibly. The entitlement charged to the short-sold loan can't be restored until VA's loss is repaid, but you may still have remaining entitlement for another VA loan. In high-cost areas it may not be enough for zero down. Get a COE and a lender's remaining-entitlement estimate before you choose a short sale.
A short sale itself doesn't require you to live in the home, but VA's $1,500 relocation payment is described for borrower occupants. If the home is tenant-occupied, ask your servicer in writing whether you qualify, and remember that Hawaii's landlord-tenant code still protects your tenant during the sale.
In a short sale, you sell to a buyer and the servicer takes the proceeds. In a deed in lieu, you sign the home over to the servicer instead. VA expects servicers to consider a short sale first. A deed in lieu needs clear title with no other liens and a home left broom clean. Both can carry the $1,500 relocation payment.
VA doesn't publish a standard timeline. The liquidation appraisal VA uses is generally valid for 180 days. On past Oahu short sales our team has handled, approvals have ranged from under 90 days to about four and a half months. If you have PCS orders, start as soon as you know the sale won't cover the loan.
All checked November 20, 2026 (HST).